[Movie] Batman vs Superman: Dawn of Alfred 8

Batman vs Superman is the story of an engineering genius named Alfred who has decided to dedicate his life in service to the Wayne family as a butler, much to his detriment. As not-so-young-any-more Master Bruce goes into an out-of-control spiral of obsession laced with extremely lucid an violent dreams that really ought to have him seeking out help from a mental health professionals, Alfred does the best he can to get him to reel it in, with such pointed remarks as, “…the feeling of powerlessness that turns good men cruel.” Alfred can only watch in growing dismay as Bruce becomes completely fixated on Superman as a symbol of all things wrong, presumably resentful because Superman is way better at murdering people than Bruce, and is also the most popular girl at prom. It’s the story of one man being slowly crushed under the weight of another man’s insurmountable ego, as Alfred laments, “Go upstairs and socialize. Some young lady will make you honest… in your dreams, Alfred.” Ultimately, Alfred’s soul becomes one more piece of collateral damage in the massive manpain dick-waving contest that occurs between Batman and Superman, thankfully cut short by the intervention of a badass woman wielding a sword and round shield, who is the only person capable of finding some sort of joy in this entire film. Maybe she will make the dark knight an honest man and answer Alfred’s dying hopes, but I wouldn’t want to inflict that on her, she deserves so much better, and it’s obvious from the way she’s willing to dive into battle and take her hits with a fierce grin, having at last found a worthy opponent.

In case you couldn’t tell, the only parts of this movie I liked were Alfred (Jeremy Irons) and Wonder Woman (Gal Gadot), who probably accounted for less than 5% of the film’s running time. (My driving away from the movie reaction here, since Didi asked for it.)

I’m not surprised I didn’t like this movie. I really didn’t care for Man of Steel, and in Batman vs Superman, Zack Snyder makes a film that’s even less coherent than the first. Even worse, the soundtrack for this one is bombastic, overblown, and oddly desperate, which is the cherry on the shit sundae, kind of like the soundtrack for Transformers 4 sucking. (The only good bit of the soundtrack was when Wonder Woman showed up, holy shit that guitar though.) You leave me with nothing, Snyder. But I decided that I would see BvS anyway because 1) Wonder Woman and 2) Alfred, and at least they didn’t disappoint. Also, it’s hard to justify saying mean things about a movie if you haven’t seen it (particularly egregious nonsense like Gods of Egypt excepted) no matter how much of a hot mess it looks in the trailers.

As usual, Zack Snyder makes a film that’s visually appealing (if so ridiculously color filtered that at times it looks almost black and white) and lacks any sort of sequential or narrative coherence as shots form scenes. It also feels like he jammed at least three movies together and the plot just bounces between them all like a frantic pingpong ball. We get the Batman origin story again. We get Lex Luthor coming out of left field (way the fuck out in left field, more on this in a minute) and doing some kind of six dimensional villain chess thing that’s so poorly developed it’s impossible to follow. We get Wonder Woman trying to set up the Justice League, squeezed into a few spare seconds. We get Bruce’s manpain, and more manpain, and even more manpain, and then some bizarre dream sequences that really don’t add a fucking thing. We get Superman getting called in front of Congress and constantly talked about as what a giant threat he is because everyone likes him, which seems very weird when in the movie literally no one but Lois Lane seems to like Superman until we’re midway through the second act and he finally rescues some people from a burning factory. (By the way, Lois Lane and Clark have a couple really cute scenes and kudos for that tiny sliver of character development.)

Henry Cavill tries with Superman, bless him, you can tell he’s trying so hard as someone who gets the character under a director who plainly doesn’t. But I honestly laughed out loud when Ma Kent reassures Clark that he’s not a killer. Actually, Ma, we have Zack Snyder and the previous movie to thank for that. Though I will note that Clark goes out of his way in this movie to try to not murder a lot of civilians, and that I appreciated. But it’s a bit ridiculous when his supposed reason for going after Batman is that Batman is brutal and causing people to die. Your body count is still way higher, kiddo. But it doesn’t help that even Superman doesn’t seem to know why the fuck Superman is doing anything, perhaps because Zack Snyder doesn’t get it either, and Ma Kent acts as reverse Uncle Ben, assuring her son that, “I never wanted the world to have you… you don’t owe this world a thing. You never did.” (Ma Kent’s an objectivist, who would have thought.)

Of course Ben Affleck’s Batman is another step in the descent of this character becoming the Punisher Lite. There’s only one fight in the entire goddamn movie where it really feels like he’s fighting like Batman, using hand to hand and ninja skills and gadgets instead of shooting things and blowing up cars and basically murdering people left and right, even if he doesn’t do it personally. This version of Batman, charmingly enough, brands people with the bat symbol so that when they get sent to prison, they get murdered by the inmates. This is a thing he plainly knows is happening. It’s as if Snyder took a look at the Bale/Nolan Batman and went, yeah, but this guy is way too likable and morally upright. Now, why he’s got a hate-on for Superman makes sense in a strictly hypocritical fashion–it’s okay to murder people when you’re Batman, but Superman is just way too good at it. Obviously this cannot be allowed to stand, and thus some kind of battle, blah blah blah manpain manpain angst angst posturing oh wait we need to unite to defeat a common enemy that gets airdropped in at the last minute. (Though I will note that I think Ben Affleck did a fine job with what precious little he had, and I’d actually really like to see more Batfleck if he’s in a movie that isn’t directed by Zack Snyder.)

Maybe if you liked Man of Steel, you’ll like this. Maybe Zack Snyder movies are for you. But if you’re like me, just wait for some perfect soul to make a super cut that’s nothing but Wonder Woman (or ideally, Wonder Woman and Alfred) and watch it on youtube. Don’t worry, there’s a much, much better Batman movie coming soon.

The worst part of all of this is I’m going to drag myself to whatever DC does next as long as Gal Gadot is in it, because I’m that fucking thirsty for a female superhero movie. So hell yeah, I will still show for a Wonder Woman movie, even if Zack Snyder ends up directing it, (bless Farli for pointing out that Patty Jenkins is directing Wonder Woman, I can feel hope again!) because I love Wonder Woman and still have hope in my heart that hasn’t been entirely crushed that maybe she will get the treatment she deserves. (Her five minutes in BvS was pretty good.) But I sure don’t have a reason to trust her movie won’t suck, not after the way this one ended.

SPOILERS for the end from this point, if you even care.

The real question of BvS is what the fuck the deal is with Lex Luthor, and I still couldn’t tell you. If he had a coherent point that spoke to his motivations anywhere in the film, it was lost in the hyperactive, Hollywood-manic way Jesse Eisenberg played him. (Apparently this is “millennial” Lex Luthor. I’m now incredibly offended on behalf of the millennials.) Why the fuck did Zack Snyder decide that was the way to go with Lex Luthor? None of what he does make sense. None of his manipulations make sense. The Joker did it a thousand times better across every one of his incarnations. His ultimate purpose seems to be facilitating the fight between Batman and Superman, and he still can’t manage to do so without kidnapping Clark’s mom and threatening to kill her if Clark doesn’t murder Batman. Why is he doing any of this? If he wants Superman dead so bad and wants Batman to do it, why work so hard to keep Bruce from getting the kryptonite? Who the fuck knows! Have some explosions!

Of course, the number one most insulting thing about this movie is the way that fight plays out. It ends with Batman, his boot literally on Superman’s neck, threatening to stab him with a spear made out of fucking kryptonite, and Clark manages to gasp out something about Martha. Because Ma Kent’s name is Martha, and Lex Luthor is going to have her set on fire by mercenaries from yet another dangling subplot. And Batman is like, Martha? Who told you that name? My mom’s name is Martha! LET’S BE FRIENDS.

I am not even making this shit up. I couldn’t make this shit up if I tried. Because two seconds later, Bruce is flying in to rescue Ma Kent (in the only fight where Batman actually acts like Batman as we know him in this movie) and tell her that he’s a friend of her son’s. Well okay then.

Then there’s a major fight with something that’s like half Zod and half Jesse Eisenberg because why the fuck not, nothing else Lex Luthor does makes any fucking sense either, you know he’s just that kind of guy because he wears canvas sneakers with his suits. And then Superman dies.

Yes. You heard that right. Superman gets killed by the Zodenberg as he’s stabbing it with Batman’s kryptonite spear. DC in its infinite wisdom decided to START their Justice League movies off with the death of Superman. But don’t worry, kids, he’s not actually dead. The dirt over his coffin is levitating.

Fuck this movie.

8 thoughts on “[Movie] Batman vs Superman: Dawn of Alfred

  1. Reply Sin Mar 27,2016 13:47

    The Power of Martha compels them to be friends and it really was like the Joker was wearing a Lex Luthor suit. At least we had Wonder Woman (she looked even more badass in that WWI photo) and Alfred.

    • Reply Rachael Mar 27,2016 13:49


      I actually just bought the one track on the soundtrack that had Wonder Woman’s theme in it. Because godDAMN.

      • Reply Beth Rasmussen Mar 29,2016 18:03

        I liked the first soundtrack so much (why I actually wen to MoS) — so I preordered this one. *sigh* But from the digital booklet — Wonder Woman’s theme (which I also loved) was an electric cello. ;)

  2. Pingback: Batman V Superman and the Pleasures of Excess | David Annandale

  3. Reply Beth Rasmussen Mar 29,2016 18:02

    The Lex thing was weird. It was like genius abused orphan manipulates a traumatized unhinged orphan — both with too much time & money available.
    (I always thought Batty was traumatized — but the crazy was new.)

    The weirdest thing was how the whole issue Congress & everybody were outraged as if Sups was saying he was a god/whathaveyou for no real reason. There was a bit of news program with the Talking Heads discussing Superman and there was ONE guy who said he’s not trying to be god/devil — just trying to do the right thing when possible?

    But what I got from the many Lex rants — his Daddy beat him, God didn’t stop him (so no God can be all good), Superman could possible be a God — so he has to make the world hate/see Superman isn’t all good – because no saved him from his crazy father? Oo

  4. Reply Forkmaster Mar 30,2016 03:39

    I couldn’t agree more. This review is EXACTLY how I felt when I left the theatre, and the main problem is that it could have been so good. If they had focused on the different ideals of Superman and Batman and the tension rising between them WITHOUT Lex Luthor actually having anything to do with it, skipping Doomsday entirely and left out the whole “This is not a sequel to Man of Steel but a set-up for the Justice League-movie” it could have been good. Marvel took their time and built up each character before rushing along. Now I feel Age of Ultron had the same problem where it didn’t focus on the movie itself but rather setting up Phase 3, they still have a better track-record.

Leave a Reply